Extremist Republicans have sided with Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and President Obama once again. To be exact, 18 Republicans joined with the liberals and abandoned 158 of their colleagues. Ironically, none of their votes were required for passage of the bill and 17 Democrats adopted a common sense position on this bill.
What is the big deal? If someone kills or beats up a heterosexual, white, Christian they get a "normal" conviction. If someone kills a non-white, non-Christian, non-heterosexual they get a much longer prison sentence. So much for "equal protection" under the law.
In fact, this law makes it clear that if it is "perceived" that the crime was motivated by hate, the extra penalties would apply. How does the government "perceive" if that is the case? How do they prove it?
Forgive me, but if someone kills or beats up someone, isn't that "hate" in and of itself? Why is it worse to kill or beat up someone as compared to someone else? Doesn't equality mean equality? Not for liberals and these extremist Republicans.
As usual, the language is so vague that there are worries that charges like "conspiracy" or "incitement to violence" could apply.
So if a religious person preaches or states that homosexuality is "wrong" or "sinful" and someone kills or beats up a gay person, the person who UTTERED the words could also be found guilty of a "hate crime". Paranoid? Hardly. In Canada this is becoming routine. In fact, just like Canada, internet communications, and presumably even emails, could be designated as hate crimes even if no other crime was committed!
Here is an interesting opinion piece in the uberconservative magazine TIME:
http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1849412,00.html
How did our Pennsylvania Congressional delegation vote?: http://clerk.house.gov/cgi-bin/vote.asp?year=2009&rollnumber=223
Yes:
Dent (R-15th)
Gerlach (R-6th)
Todd Platts (R-19th)
Chaka Fattah (D-2nd)
Mike Doyle (D-14th)
Joe Sestak (D-7th)
Allyson Schwartz (D-13th)
Kathleen Dahlkemper (D-3rd)
Paul Kanjorski (D-11th)
Tim Holden (D-17th)
Robert Brady (D-1st)
Patrick Murphy (D-8th)
Jason Altmire (D-4th)
No:
Glenn Thompson (R-5th)
Bill Shuster (R-9th)
Chris Carney (D-10th)
Joe Pitts (R-16th)
Tim Murphy (R-18th)
No Vote:
John Murtha (D-12th)
'New Moon' shatters box-office records
1 hour ago